In common with mosts sites on the web, this site uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Find out more about cookies  Accept & Close

A People without a Land on JMAN.tv - The Best Documentaries... Instantly On Demand

The world's best documentaries, from Wikileaks to Lance Armstrong. Available to stream instantly for £1 rental or unlimited access subscription.

- Please do not use this film as a teaching aid without purchasing an educational licence.
Is the patchwork of remaining Palestinian land is now so fragmented it could never form a viable future state? This incisive film asks whether the settlers have finally destroyed any chance of anything but a single homogeneous Palestinian Jewish state.

"We have to expel them", says an Israeli youth impatiently, speaking of Arabs. "All of them." "Come again?" His interviewer replies. This young man is taking a seemingly radical line on the possibility of a " one state solution." But the belief that peaceful coexistence is impossible - and that Jewish people have an exclusive, God-given right to live in Israel - is hardly rare. More troublingly, opposition to a one-state solution is not confined to the radical right. Arnon Soffer is a university professor who considers the possibility of a Palestinian majority in Israel untenable. "If you endanger the Jewishness of my country, my compromise will be on democracy", he says. But is it more untenable to live "in a state in which any minority is a demographic threat"? Asks Neta Golan, co-founder of a pro-Palestine NGO. She says bluntly: "It's a recipe for apartheid."

She's not the only Israeli critical of her nation's past. In A People Without A Land we meet the remarkable Eitan Bronstein, a former soldier who served time for his refusal to fight in the 1982 Lebanon War. Bronstein later founded an organisation dedicated to fostering Israeli-Palestinian understanding. He believes a single state founded on equality for all citizens is the only possible solution.

Soffer demurs. "After the last terrible 100 years, of so many hatreds and wars, they will accept me - with love?" He laughs. Even the authors of 'The One State Condition' are cautious, recognising Israel's traumatic history. The one state solution "is not a solution, at the moment. It's a vision... but as a vision, this is my vision. I would like to dream about this possibility."

Few films succeed as well as this one in historically contextualising the modern state of Israel. Enriched by interviews across the political, ethical and religious spectrum, A Land Without A People should be required viewing.

Comments

 
  • 1.  VictorM 03 Sep 2015 22:36

    Just getting started.

  • 2.  VictorM 03 Sep 2015 22:37

    Just getting started.

Create an account with your post below.
If you already have a JMAN.tv account, just Login & Post

Just letters, numbers and underscore(_).
This is your unique name on JMAN.tv
  
(This will be your JMAN.tv login)
We don't Spam & your email is kept private.
  
Confirmation of your login email entered above.   
Just letters and numerals   
Just letters, numerals and spaces     
Please enter the 5 character code from the image below   
Please check the box to confirm the terms and conditions I agree
to the JMAN.tv T & C's and Privacy Policy.